Why Australian Politics Refused to Ban Shackles in Childbirth While Pushing Social Media Reform

Why Australian Politics Refused to Ban Shackles in Childbirth While Pushing Social Media Reform

Picture someone in active labor, strapped to a hospital bed with restraints, while lawmakers in Canberra spend their energy drafting rules about social media feeds. Sounds upside down, right?

That exact clash has defined recent Australian politics. In mid-October 2026, both Labor and the Coalition moved to block a vote on independent Senator Lidia Thorpe’s federal bill to ban the shackling of incarcerated women during childbirth—alongside a separate push to stop strip-searches of children in custody. Around the same stretch of parliamentary work, Communications Minister Anika Wells pressed ahead with sweeping social media reforms, including the Digital Duty of Care framework ("My Feed, My Way") and stronger powers for the eSafety Commissioner.

If you're searching for what happened on the floor of Australian politics, you probably want two straight answers. First, why did the two major parties block a ban on restraining women giving birth? Second, what is Anika Wells actually changing in social media law, and why do these two stories keep colliding in public debate?

Why Labor and the Coalition Blocked the Childbirth Shackling Bill

Let's cut through the political spin first. Neither Labor nor the Coalition stood up in the Senate to argue that restraining a woman in labor is great medical practice. Instead, both major parties leaned on a familiar Australian federalist excuse: prisons belong to the states and territories.

By blocking a vote on Senator Lidia Thorpe’s bill in October 2026, Canberra avoided binding federal rules on state correctional systems. Supporters of the bill—including First Nations advocates and health bodies like the Congress of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Nurses and Midwives—have argued that restraining pregnant or birthing people undermines safe, respectful maternity care and puts both parent and baby at risk. Meanwhile, critics of the block say the Commonwealth already holds constitutional levers to set national baseline standards when fundamental rights are on the line, calling the "states' responsibility" line a political choice rather than a hard legal wall.

Even inside the Coalition, the move wasn't completely unanimous. Liberal Senator Paul Scarr broke ranks to condemn the major parties' handling of the issue, signalling that he would write to Queensland's attorney-general. And at the state level, pressure hasn't gone away—in Victoria, for instance, the Greens announced plans to push state-level legislation to ban shackling during childbirth after federal efforts stalled.

When a federal ban gets blocked, the gap doesn't just sit on paper—it plays out in hospital wards. Correctional rules across Australian states often treat restraints as an exception rather than a flat prohibition, leaving room for discretionary approval or case-by-case security classifications.

Clinicians and researchers studying custodial health have repeatedly pointed out the practical mess this creates. Midwives and obstetricians need freedom of movement to respond quickly if labor stalls, blood pressure spikes, or an emergency C-section becomes necessary. Chains, cuffs, or belly belts can slow down clinical care, heighten trauma—especially for Indigenous women already overrepresented in custody—and sever early bonding right after delivery.

In my view, hiding behind state boundaries on an issue like childbirth restraints looks weak. A modern democracy can figure out how to keep a hospital room safe without putting metal on someone mid-contraction.

What Anika Wells Is Pushing on Social Media Reform

While the Senate ducked a vote on custodial restraints, Communications Minister Anika Wells has been front and center on tech regulation. Australia already made global headlines with its under-16 social media age restrictions under the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act 2024, which rolled out enforcement requirements across major platforms.

Now the Albanese government is moving to the next phase: a Digital Duty of Care—branded publicly as "My Feed, My Way"—paired with tougher enforcement powers for the eSafety Commissioner. Instead of waiting for harm to explode after a feature launches, a statutory duty of care shifts legal responsibility onto platforms to design safer systems upfront and give users real control over their feeds.

Under the consultation framework rolled out in September and October 2026, key elements include:

  • Proactive harm prevention: Platforms face expectations to mitigate risks rather than relying purely on reactive takedowns.
  • Targeted protections for under-18s: Guardrails against content linked to eating disorders, misogyny and gender hostility, pornography, dangerous stunts or crime glorification, and severe bullying or distress.
  • Stronger investigative teeth: Expanding eSafety powers—including authority to summon individuals such as executives or former employees during compliance probes—alongside steep penalties for breaches.
  • User agency: Giving Australians clearer options over algorithmic feeds rather than trapping people in endless engagement loops.

Where Social Media Rules Get Messy

Big tech regulation always sounds straightforward in a press release, and much harder once code meets reality. Earlier age-verification rollouts already showed how teens find workarounds, how platforms tweak recommendation algorithms in unexpected ways, and how some young people feel cut off from peer spaces when access tightens.

There's also a genuine tension between safety and overreach. If laws define "harmful" too loosely, platforms may over-block legitimate discussion, art, or support communities just to dodge multi-million-dollar fines. Getting the balance right takes careful drafting—not just loud headlines.

Why These Two Stories Collide in Australian Politics

At first glance, custodial maternity care and social media algorithms belong in completely different folders. Yet covering Australian politics live often puts them side by side because both test where the federal government draws its moral and legal lines.

With social media, Canberra has shown appetite for bold, headline-grabbing federal intervention and hefty corporate penalties. With incarcerated women giving birth, the two big parties chose caution, jurisdiction, and the status quo. Voters watching that contrast notice the disparity fast: aggressive federal muscle for tech platforms, and a shrug of "ask the states" for people in prison cells.

That doesn't mean social media reform is bad policy or that prison reform is simple. It means voters are paying attention to priorities—and calling out the double standard when they spot one.

Practical Next Steps If You're Following or Taking Action

If you want to stay grounded on these debates rather than relying on hot takes, a few concrete moves make a real difference:

  1. Track the exact bills and committee stages: Follow federal Senate notices and committee inquiries on custodial rights alongside the Department of Infrastructure and Communications releases from Anika Wells so you can separate draft proposals from passed law.
  2. Check your own state or territory's rules: Because corrections policy varies across jurisdictions, look up your state's corrective services commissioner guidelines or human rights commission reports if you want to know what applies locally.
  3. Read submissions from frontline experts: Health bodies, legal aid groups, and youth mental health organisations often publish sharper critiques of both prison practices and online safety rules than political soundbites ever offer.
  4. Write directly to your local MP or senator: Keep your note short, specific, and focused on one bill or policy—state your view clearly, ask where they stand on the vote or consultation, and request a direct reply rather than a form letter.

Politics moves fast, and live blogs can make every procedural skirmish feel like the end of the story. Usually, it's just the opening round.

NH

Naomi Hughes

A dedicated content strategist and editor, Naomi Hughes brings clarity and depth to complex topics. Committed to informing readers with accuracy and insight.