The L.A. County Superior Court Judge Office 87 election is a textbook example of how consequential power gets decided behind a curtain of voter fatigue. Voters across Los Angeles County face dozens of nonpartisan trial court seats on a single ballot, often with zero incumbent to defend a record and minimal press coverage explaining what a trial judge actually does. In the 2026 cycle for Office 87, deputy public defender Anthony "A.J." Bayne and complex litigator David DeJute advanced past primary rival Sharee Gordon to a November runoff, turning an obscure numbered seat into a quiet proxy battle over courtroom philosophy, institutional backing, and who gets to shape everyday justice in the nation's largest county trial court.
I have covered local courts and municipal politics long enough to know that voters rarely wake up excited about numbered judicial offices. Most people treat them like a pop quiz they didn't study for. Yet a Superior Court judge wields immediate, personal authority over liberty, family stability, property disputes, and civil liability—decisions that affect daily life far more directly than a speech in Congress. If you found value in this post, you should check out: this related article.
Why Voters Go In Blind on Office 87
Numbered judicial races are structural blind spots by design. California's trial court elections are officially nonpartisan, meaning candidates do not run with a party label next to their names on the ballot. Without a familiar partisan shortcut, many voters skip the race entirely or guess based on a two- or three-word ballot occupation line.
That ballot line carries heavy freight. When a candidate lists a title like "Deputy Public Defender" or "Attorney," voters project an entire worldview onto those words. Some assume a public defender is soft on crime; others argue decades inside a criminal courtroom builds a sharp, practical grasp of constitutional rights, evidentiary rules, and human fallibility. Meanwhile, a private-sector litigator may be seen as bringing broad civil and commercial command, or criticized for lacking high-volume trial-court trenches experience. For another perspective on this story, see the recent update from The Washington Post.
Turnout dynamics compound the problem. Primary elections in June draw a smaller, older, more activist slice of the electorate, while general elections in November pull in broader crowds who often encounter judicial candidates for the first time while holding a ballot. In Office 87, Bayne finished first in the June 2 primary with 694,004 votes (42.0%), DeJute took second with 516,631 votes (31.3%), and Sharee Gordon placed third with 440,136 votes (26.7%). More than 1.65 million ballots were cast in that primary contest alone, yet a huge share of those voters likely knew little beyond basic biographical snippets.
A numbered seat on a county ballot looks like trivia on paper. Inside the courtroom, it is raw discretion over bail, sentencing, motions, and civil survival.
Two Very Different Legal Tracks
The runoff between Anthony "A.J." Bayne and David DeJute put two distinct career paths side by side. Neither path guarantees perfection on the bench, and each comes with real trade-offs that voters rarely hear debated in plain English.
| Factor | Anthony "A.J." Bayne | David DeJute |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Legal Identity | Longtime deputy public defender in Los Angeles County | Complex litigation attorney and legal educator |
| Core Day-to-Day Arena | High-volume criminal defense and felony courtroom trials | High-stakes civil litigation, class actions, and appellate/teaching work |
| June 2026 Primary Result | First place with 694,004 votes (42.0%) | Second place with 516,631 votes (31.3%) |
| Key Rating / Backing Signal | Rated "Well Qualified" by the Los Angeles County Bar Association | Endorsed by various Democratic clubs and civic/business groups |
The Criminal Trenches Argument
Bayne built his pitch around more than three decades of legal work and over 25 years as a deputy public defender handling serious felony matters and jury trials. Supporter arguments for this background are straightforward. A seasoned trial lawyer knows how rules of evidence work under pressure, how juries react in real time, and how overcrowded dockets move when dozens of cases are called before lunch.
Critics of a defense-heavy profile sometimes worry about perceived leniency or friction with prosecutors. Supporters counter that good judging isn't about rooting for the defense or the prosecution—it is about enforcing standards of proof, managing calendars efficiently, and treating defendants, victims, witnesses, and lawyers with evenhanded firmness.
The Complex Litigation and Broad-Practice Argument
DeJute pointed to a mix of public service, private litigation, legal aid, and teaching, including complex civil disputes and law-related instruction. Proponents of that mix argue that Superior Court judges handle far more than criminal dockets—they preside over contract fights, employment claims, family matters, probate, and civil lawsuits where written briefing, statutory interpretation, and calm case management matter deeply.
Skeptics of a primarily civil or appellate/academic track sometimes ask whether a candidate has spent enough hours managing fast-moving criminal calendars or contested evidentiary objections on their feet. In truth, every new judge—regardless of background—faces a learning curve when assigned to an unfamiliar calendar.
What Bar Ratings and Endorsements Actually Tell You
When voters don't know the candidates personally, they lean on proxies. Bar association evaluations and slate mailers are the two biggest ones in Los Angeles County, and neither is a magic decoder ring.
The Los Angeles County Bar Association evaluates judicial candidates through its Judicial Elections Evaluation Committee, reviewing questionnaires, interviewing references, and issuing ratings such as "Well Qualified". A top rating from lawyers and judges who actually practice in local courtrooms carries real weight because it reflects peer scrutiny of temperament, competence, and ethics. Still, bar ratings are evaluations of readiness and legal acumen, not a guarantee of how a judge will exercise discretion years later.
Endorsements tell a murkier story. In nonpartisan races, groups that don't always agree on policy—ranging from labor unions and law enforcement associations to progressive clubs, business-minded coalitions, and local Democratic clubs—sometimes split or endorse candidates based on personal relationships, slate politics, or campaign outreach. A long list of endorsements proves a campaign worked the phones and coalitions. It does not replace reading what each candidate actually says about fairness, timeliness, and judicial restraint.
The Governor Appointment Factor Nobody Mentions
Here is a piece of institutional reality that gets lost in almost every election guide. Most Superior Court judges in California do not reach the bench by winning an election first; they get there through gubernatorial appointment when a judge retires, steps down, or a new seat is created, and then stand for election later.
Open-seat elections without an incumbent—like Office 87—are rarer and more contested because voters get a direct choice before an appointee settles in. Once a judge takes office, their day-to-day performance rarely makes headlines unless a ruling sparks controversy or a misconduct complaint triggers review by the California Commission on Judicial Performance. That makes upfront scrutiny before casting a ballot doubly important.
How to Judge a Judicial Candidate Without Guessing
You don't need a law degree to make a smart call in an L.A. County Superior Court race. Focus on four concrete signals instead of slogans:
- Check the bar evaluation first. Look at whether a candidate earned a "Well Qualified" or lower rating and read any available committee notes on temperament and experience.
- Match experience to the court's workload. Look closely at actual courtroom hours, trial exposure, and substantive areas practiced rather than generic claims of "broad experience".
- Look past famous names on endorsements. Ask why a group backed a candidate—shared legal philosophy, local ties, or strategic slate alignment—rather than counting logos.
- Watch for judicial temperament. The best trial judges are prepared, decisive, courteous to self-represented litigants and lawyers alike, and slow to anger when a calendar runs late.
An election for a single numbered seat rarely changes the world overnight. Over a six-year term, though, one judge's habits on preparation, fairness, and efficiency shape hundreds of lives a year.