Inside the Rams Kicking Collapse That Ended Harrison Mevis

Inside the Rams Kicking Collapse That Ended Harrison Mevis

The Los Angeles Rams waived kicker Harrison Mevis in mid-October 2026 after a 37-34 overtime loss to the Buffalo Bills in which Mevis missed a 50-yard field goal in the first quarter and had a potential game-winning 48-yard attempt blocked in overtime. That single Monday night sequence capped an uneven five-game stretch that dropped his 2026 field-goal mark to five makes on nine attempts and pushed the front office to sign Blake Grupe off the New York Jets practice squad. Yet treating Mevis as the sole culprit misses how a once-reliable late-season and playoff weapon unraveled inside a broader special teams slide.

A Rapid Rise Turned Into a Five-Game Slide

Football seasons move fast. Less than a year before his exit, Mevis looked like a rare midseason bargain who could steady a high-scoring offense.

After signing onto the Los Angeles practice squad in November 2025 and stepping into regular-season action, Mevis connected on 12 of 13 field-goal attempts and all 39 extra-point tries across nine games. He carried that accuracy into the postseason, going six-for-six on field goals—including a game-winner in the Divisional Round at Chicago—and nine-for-nine on extra points. A strong spring in the UFL with the Birmingham Stallions, where he converted over 95 percent of his regular-season kicks and went spotless in the postseason, reinforced the belief that his compact 5-foot-11, 240-plus-pound frame generated plenty of leg pop without sacrificing precision.

Preseason 2026 offered no warning signs either. Mevis finished exhibition play six-for-six on field goals and eight-for-eight on extra points.

Once the games counted for real, the margin shrank. Across the first five weeks of the 2026 season, Mevis struggled with consistency beyond medium range and saw his overall conversion rate dip to 55.6 percent. Head coach Sean McVay did not sugarcoat the kicking unit's performance after the overtime defeat to Buffalo, calling the kicking game "not even close to good enough" in a game where every possession mattered.

Anatomy of a Monday Night Collapse

One kick can swing a locker room. Two kicks in the same game can end a tenure.

Against Buffalo on October 12, 2026, Mevis started poorly by missing a 50-yard field goal in the opening quarter. That early miss set an uncomfortable tone for an offense trading punches with a tough opponent in a game that eventually stretched past regulation.

The decisive blow came in overtime. Lining up for a 48-yard attempt that could have ended the night for Los Angeles, Mevis saw his kick tipped by Bills defensive end Greg Rousseau. A blocked or tipped kick is never just a kicker stat; it points to timing between the snap, the hold, and the kick itself, as well as protection up front against interior and edge rushers. Still, in the unforgiving math of NFL roster management, a 48-yard overtime miss—regardless of how it gets altered—sits right next to the kicker's name.

Metric / Period Record / Stat Context
2025 Regular Season 12/13 FG (92.3%), 39/39 XP Joined late in season across nine games
2025 Postseason 6/6 FG, 9/9 XP Hit Divisional Round game-winner at Chicago
2026 Preseason 6/6 FG, 8/8 XP Clean three-game exhibition slate
2026 Regular Season (Weeks 1–5) 5/9 FG (55.6%), 14/14 XP Missed 50-yarder and had 48-yard OT kick blocked vs. BUF

Why Special Teams Went Sideways in Los Angeles

Blaming a single specialist is easy. Fixing a broken third phase is much harder.

Look at the wider special teams picture in Los Angeles over the 2025 and 2026 seasons, and the Harrison Mevis release starts to look like a symptom rather than the whole disease. Coverage and return units have lagged near the bottom of the league in key yardage categories, while punting efficiency has also trailed the pack. When a team loses field-position battles consistently, its kicker faces longer, lower-percentage attempts or operates under tighter scorelines where a single miss feels fatal.

Consider a hypothetical scenario to see how that pressure compounds: suppose a kicker enters a game knowing two earlier drives stalled outside the red zone and the coverage unit just surrendered a long return. Instead of stepping onto the turf with a two-score cushion on a clean 38-yarder, he walks out tied or trailing from 48 to 50 yards with rushers bearing down. Every fraction of a second in the operation slows down, and trajectory has to be higher to clear outstretched hands.

That is the gray area that standard box scores rarely capture. A kicker can lose rhythm because of his own mechanics—dropping his plant foot slightly off target, rushing his hip rotation, or changing his approach angle—or because the protection and operation around him are leaking oil. Often, both happen at once, eroding trust between coaches and specialists until a single prime-time loss forces a reset.

What Signing Blake Grupe Actually Solves

Bringing in Blake Grupe off the Jets' practice squad gives the Rams an experienced leg who has already handled NFL regular-season pressure in New Orleans and Indianapolis. At 5-foot-7 and 156 pounds, Grupe looks nothing like the 240-plus-pound kicker he replaced, underscoring that NFL kicking is about repeatable tempo and leg whip rather than size.

Grupe's track record comes with its own caveats. During his 11-game stint with the Saints in 2025, he made 18 of 26 field goals (69.2 percent), though he bounced back with an 11-for-11 run across five games with the Colts and converted every extra point he attempted that year. That split shows both sides of the gamble: when Grupe is locked in, he is automatic, yet stretches of inaccuracy are not foreign to his resume.

For Los Angeles, the move buys immediate accountability and a fresh mental slate in the kicking room. It does not automatically fix return lanes, punt net averages, or protection breakdowns on long field goals. If the Rams want points in tight games to stop slipping away in overtime, the front office and coaching staff will have to clean up the entire special teams operation, not just swap the name on the jersey.

Buffalo Bills vs Los Angeles Rams Game Highlights | 2026 NFL Season Week 5

This highlight package shows the full overtime back-and-forth between Buffalo and Los Angeles where the kicking miscues proved decisive.

DG

Dominic Garcia

As a veteran correspondent, Dominic Garcia has reported from across the globe, bringing firsthand perspectives to international stories and local issues.